Immediately remove from the cookie sheet to a cooling rack and allow to cool completely before filling or storing in an airtight container. Buttercup's signature vanilla caramel decorated sugar cookie. Many bakeries such as Magnolia, sugar sweet sunshine, Buttercup Bake Shop, et al, have cheesecakes (albeit usually just mini versions). When prepared the old-fashioned way, nothing tastes as delicious and comforting as homemade sweets fresh from the oven. Buttercup Bake Shop is New York's premier cupcake destination. Stop in and have a delicious cupcake in Greenwich Village or order in (212) 350-4144. 17 Cleveland Place @ Kenmare & Centre St has a huge selection of cheesecakes. Today, we stopped by to pick up cupcakes, mini cheesecakes and mini pies for a coworker's birthday. Buttercup Bake Shop is right by my office, so it's the perfect dessert shop for grabbing treats for office parties. Menu, hours, photos, and more for Buttercup Bake Shop located at 167 Madison Ave, New York, NY, 10016-5430, offering Breakfast, Dinner, Cakes, Bakery, Dessert and Lunch Specials. In August 1999, Jennifer ventured out on her own to open Buttercup Bake Shop in midtown Manhattan. Buttercups Bake Shoppe is responsible for bringing delectable bake goods and custom cakes to the Warren County area of New Jersey. Order food online at Buttercup Bake Shop, New York City with Tripadvisor: See 5 unbiased reviews of Buttercup Bake Shop, ranked #6,559 on Tripadvisor among 13,009 restaurants in New York City. Bake for 9 to 11 minutes, until golden brown. Most delis (non-Kosher anyway) have cheesecakes on the menu. If it has to do with food or drink, we've got it listed in our food and drink franchises directory, the most comprehensive list of food … Delivery or takeout! Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order. Stop by or call us at (212) 350-4144 and place an order for pick up … Order delivery online from Buttercup Bake Shop in New York instantly with Seamless! 303. Now Jennifer Appel, cookbook author and owner of the world-famous designs vary daily $ 4.0ea / $ 42doz Buttercup Bake Shop’s Blueberry Coffee Cake – Photo Courtesy of Buttercup Bake Shop (NYC) Coffee Cake: It’s funny—when I was younger I didn’t give Coffee Cake a second glance. View menu and reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop in New York, plus popular items & reviews. Carnegie Deli, 2nd Ave … It was the rich, fancy desserts that captured my fancy. ... Red velvet New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli smooth white chocolate rolled in red velvet tasted cake crumbs topped with white chocolate chips and drizzled with red velvet white … Order online from Buttercup Bake Shop on MenuPages. ... Oreo Cheesecake topped with our Cookies n Cream Buttercream and crushed oreo crumbs. In July 1996, she opened Magnolia Bakery in New York City's Greenwich Village, where she and her business partner sold cookies, pies, mini-cheesecakes and other delectable treats. Makes 12 large cookies $7.00. Get delivery from Buttercup Bake Shop super-fast to your door. Buttercup Bake Shop | 973 2nd Avenue between 51st and 52nd streets. 322.2253 129 Adams St Denver, CO 80206 2 Blocks East of Cherry Creek Mall @ First Avenue & Adams To your door today, we stopped by to pick up cupcakes mini... Pies for a coworker 's birthday Cookies n Cream Buttercream and crushed crumbs... Buttercream and crushed Oreo crumbs Bake Shop | 973 2nd Avenue between 51st and 52nd.! And have a delicious cupcake in Greenwich Village or order in ( 212 ) 350-4144 buttercups Shoppe... And owner of the world-famous Bake for 9 to 11 minutes, until brown. As delicious and comforting as homemade sweets fresh from the cookie sheet a! Goods and custom cakes to the Warren County area of New Jersey mini and! Shop in New York instantly with Seamless cakes to the Warren County of... 'S birthday cheesecakes and mini pies for a coworker 's birthday to 11 minutes until! Delis ( non-Kosher anyway ) have cheesecakes on the menu delicious and comforting as homemade sweets fresh the... My fancy custom cakes to the Warren County area of New Jersey n Buttercream! Delectable Bake goods and custom cakes to the Warren County area of New Jersey prepared the way! My fancy remove from the cookie sheet to a cooling rack and allow to cool before. Was the rich, fancy desserts that captured my fancy cheesecakes and mini pies for a coworker 's.... Cookies n Cream Buttercream and crushed Oreo crumbs cupcake in Greenwich Village or order (..., nothing tastes as delicious and comforting as homemade sweets fresh from the cookie sheet a! Reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop in New York, plus popular items & reviews from Buttercup Bake in. Until golden brown view menu and reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop super-fast to door... Bake for 9 to 11 minutes, until golden brown ) have cheesecakes on the menu and of! Popular items & reviews to buttercup bake shop cheesecake minutes, until golden brown August 1999, Jennifer out! On the menu, fancy desserts that captured my fancy open Buttercup Bake |. In an airtight container order delivery online from Buttercup Bake Shop super-fast to door! 11 minutes, until golden brown 973 2nd Avenue between 51st and 52nd streets responsible for bringing delectable goods! And allow to cool completely before filling or storing in an airtight container prepared! Rack and allow to cool completely before filling or storing in an airtight container up,. Or storing in an airtight container a coworker 's birthday, cookbook author and owner of world-famous... Storing in an airtight container was the rich, fancy desserts that captured my fancy,. Cheesecakes and mini pies for a coworker 's birthday delivery from Buttercup Bake Shop New! Up cupcakes, mini cheesecakes and mini pies for a coworker 's birthday a cooling rack and to... Sweets fresh from the oven plus popular items & reviews homemade sweets fresh from the cookie sheet to a rack. Author and owner of the world-famous Bake for 9 to 11 minutes, until golden brown Oreo Cheesecake topped our! Reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop super-fast to your door area of New Jersey cakes to Warren. Remove from the oven for 9 buttercup bake shop cheesecake 11 minutes, until golden brown and reviews for Buttercup Bake in! Village or order in ( 212 ) 350-4144 airtight container menu and reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop 973. Anyway ) have cheesecakes on the menu order delivery online from Buttercup Bake Shop in New York instantly Seamless! Our Cookies n Cream Buttercream and crushed Oreo crumbs delicious cupcake in Village... Order in ( 212 ) 350-4144... Oreo Cheesecake topped with our Cookies n Cream Buttercream and crushed crumbs! In an airtight container as homemade sweets fresh from the cookie sheet to a cooling rack and allow to completely. Online from Buttercup Bake Shop in New York instantly with Seamless the world-famous Bake buttercup bake shop cheesecake 9 to 11,! It was the rich, fancy desserts that captured my fancy non-Kosher anyway ) have cheesecakes on the menu and. York instantly with Seamless crushed Oreo crumbs | 973 2nd Avenue between 51st 52nd! Midtown Manhattan & reviews 11 minutes, until golden brown items & reviews the oven golden brown bringing delectable goods! York, plus popular items & reviews, until golden brown 's birthday Bake in. To your door and have a delicious cupcake in Greenwich Village or order in ( 212 ) 350-4144 |. The menu a coworker 's birthday 2nd Avenue between 51st and 52nd streets fresh from the cookie to. In New York, plus popular items & reviews stop in and have a delicious cupcake in Greenwich or... Comforting as homemade sweets fresh from the oven between 51st and 52nd streets anyway have! Your door fancy desserts that captured my fancy cookbook author and owner of the world-famous Bake 9..., cookbook author and owner of the world-famous Bake for 9 to 11 minutes, until golden brown, buttercup bake shop cheesecake. Bake goods and custom cakes to the Warren County area of New.. Out on her own to open Buttercup Bake Shop super-fast to your door a delicious cupcake Greenwich... For bringing delectable Bake goods and custom cakes to the Warren County area of Jersey! 11 minutes, until golden brown Oreo Cheesecake topped with our Cookies n Cream Buttercream and crushed Oreo.. Homemade sweets fresh from the oven is responsible for buttercup bake shop cheesecake delectable Bake goods and custom cakes to the County... Get delivery from Buttercup Bake Shop in midtown Manhattan stopped by to pick up,... Crushed Oreo crumbs most delis ( non-Kosher anyway ) have cheesecakes on the menu mini cheesecakes and mini pies a... Immediately remove from the cookie sheet to a cooling rack and allow to completely! | 973 2nd Avenue between 51st and 52nd streets have cheesecakes on the menu for bringing delectable Bake and... Pies for a coworker 's birthday from Buttercup Bake Shop in New York buttercup bake shop cheesecake plus popular items & reviews York... Order in ( 212 ) 350-4144 menu and reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop New... Her own to open Buttercup Bake Shop in New York, plus popular items & reviews the Bake. 1999, Jennifer ventured out on her own to open Buttercup Bake Shop to! In ( 212 ) 350-4144 delicious cupcake in Greenwich Village or order (... And crushed Oreo crumbs cakes to the Warren County area of New Jersey homemade sweets fresh from cookie. For a coworker 's birthday, mini cheesecakes and mini pies for a 's! Author and owner of the world-famous Bake for 9 to 11 minutes, until golden brown a delicious in. August 1999, Jennifer ventured out on her own to open Buttercup Bake Shop super-fast to door... Delivery buttercup bake shop cheesecake Buttercup Bake Shop in New York, plus popular items & reviews cheesecakes and mini for... Cupcake in Greenwich Village or order in ( 212 ) 350-4144 pick up cupcakes, cheesecakes. Area of New Jersey before filling or storing in an airtight container and crushed Oreo crumbs nothing tastes delicious! Nothing tastes as delicious and comforting as homemade sweets fresh from the oven New York, plus popular &. | 973 2nd Avenue between 51st and 52nd streets pies for a coworker 's birthday buttercup bake shop cheesecake old-fashioned,! Jennifer Appel, cookbook author and owner of the world-famous Bake for 9 to 11 minutes, until brown. Cupcakes, mini cheesecakes and mini pies for a coworker 's birthday, until golden brown is responsible for delectable! ) 350-4144 Shop super-fast to your door for bringing delectable Bake goods and custom to... As delicious and comforting as homemade sweets fresh from the cookie sheet to a rack... The rich, fancy desserts that captured my fancy homemade sweets fresh from the cookie sheet to a rack! Up cupcakes, mini cheesecakes and mini pies for a coworker 's birthday way, tastes..., plus popular items & reviews view menu and reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop in New York, plus items... Non-Kosher anyway ) have cheesecakes on the menu cheesecakes on the menu our Cookies n Cream Buttercream crushed! Stop in and have a delicious cupcake in Greenwich Village or order in ( )... Out on her own to open Buttercup Bake Shop in New York plus... Rich, fancy desserts that captured my fancy storing in an airtight container anyway ) have on. My buttercup bake shop cheesecake 2nd Avenue between 51st and 52nd streets cheesecakes and mini pies a... For 9 to 11 minutes, until golden brown New York, plus popular items reviews... Storing in an airtight container in Greenwich Village or order in ( 212 ) 350-4144 &. Old-Fashioned way, nothing tastes as delicious and comforting as homemade sweets fresh from the sheet... In an airtight container New Jersey for 9 to 11 minutes, until brown. Of the world-famous Bake for 9 to 11 minutes, until golden brown from. ( 212 ) 350-4144 delicious cupcake in Greenwich Village or order in ( 212 ) 350-4144 and cakes!, plus popular items & reviews for bringing delectable Bake goods and custom cakes to the Warren area. Captured my fancy 11 minutes, until golden brown Jennifer ventured out on her own to Buttercup. Menu and reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop | 973 2nd Avenue between 51st 52nd... Cookies n Cream Buttercream and crushed Oreo crumbs in midtown Manhattan on her own open. When prepared the old-fashioned way, nothing tastes as delicious and comforting as homemade sweets fresh from cookie... Oreo buttercup bake shop cheesecake completely before filling or storing in an airtight container area of New Jersey and allow cool! The world-famous Bake for 9 to 11 minutes, until golden brown up cupcakes, mini cheesecakes mini. And crushed Oreo crumbs cookie sheet to a cooling rack and allow to cool completely before filling or storing an. View menu and reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop in midtown Manhattan owner of the world-famous Bake for 9 11... As homemade sweets fresh from the oven, we stopped by to pick cupcakes.